Instrument and distribution rights
Published on 1 November 2024, the ruling concerns a Singapore listed issuer refinancing existing notes with fixed-rate subordinated perpetual securities. Distributions are independent of issuer performance, paid semi-annually in arrears and increase at specified step-up dates. The issuer may defer all or part under notice requirements without a limit on repeated deferrals. Arrears do not earn interest; specified events require full settlement, while voluntary full or partial settlement is permitted under the notice terms.
Deferral restrictions and ranking
Subject to exceptions, recent discretionary payments or capital transactions involving ordinary shares, junior obligations or non-pro-rata parity obligations block deferral. After deferral, corresponding payments and capital transactions are restricted until arrears are fully paid or an extraordinary holder resolution permits them. There is no fixed redemption date, but issuer-option redemption in specified cases pays principal plus all unpaid distributions. Claims rank behind senior creditors, at least equally with other non-junior subordinated obligations, and above share capital on insolvency.
Debt form despite equity accounting
Holders are entered in the debenture-holder register and obtain no shareholding, residual business interest, general-meeting vote or participation in operations. Payments are not limited by the Companies Act dividend-from-profits rule. Although accounted for as equity under SFRS(I) 1-32, the described facts support debt classification under section 43H(4) and QDS Regulation 2; the reasons also discuss section 13(16). Accounting equity treatment does not determine this tax conclusion.
QDS concessions and issuer deductions
Distributions and arrears are treated as interest on indebtedness, with QDS concessions and exemptions only if all other QDS conditions are satisfied. Deductibility requires examining proceeds use: capital must acquire the issuer’s taxable income, section 14 conditions must be met, and no other provision must prohibit deduction. Deduction arises only when legally due and payable, not simply on scheduled distribution dates. Non-interest-bearing arrears therefore do not justify scheduled-date deductions.
Scope and further guidance
The summary points to Income Tax Treatment of Hybrid Instruments: paragraph 5 for classification factors and paragraphs 7 and 9 for deductions and timing. It binds only this applicant and transaction, is not updated for later law or interpretations, and does not guarantee the same treatment for another perpetual instrument.
Official source
This article independently explains the substantive contents of the official PDF, including the relevant conditions, procedures and annexes. The linked document remains the authoritative source for its original wording, and later changes should be checked separately.
Read the official PDF ↗